House|Senate
112th Congress, Vote 9; Senate #223
Repealing the Health Care Bill
Official Title: A bill to modernize the air traffic control system, improve the safety, reliability, and availability of transportation by air in the United States, provide modernization of the air traffic control system, reauthorize the Federal Aviation Administration, and for other purposes.
HR 2: Repealing the Health Care Bill
Passed House January 19, 2011, 245-189.
Synopsis: HR 2 would have repealed the health care reform bill approved by Congress in 2010. In arguing for the repeal, the American Conservative Union described the Affordable Care Act as a "2,200-page monstrosity" and "the worst bill ever." The organization called for repeal of "the federal government's takeover of our health care system."
The Obama Administration, opposing the repeal, said HR 2 would "explode the deficit, raise costs for the American people and businesses, deny an estimated 32 million people health insurance, and take us back to the days when insurers could deny, limit or drop coverage for any American." President Obama said he would veto HR 2 if it was approved by the House and Senate and presented to him.
Why supporters pushed for this bill
- In arguing for the repeal, the American Conservative Union described the Affordable Care Act as a "2,200-page monstrosity" and "the worst bill ever." The organization called for repeal of "the federal government's takeover of our health care system."
- According to a study by the National Federation of Independent Businesses(NFIB) – the nation's largest small business association – the fact that the law would mandate that employers offer insurance "could lead to the elimination of 1.6 million jobs, with 66 percent of those coming from small businesses."
Why opponents tried to stop the bill
- Opposing repeal, the Administration said HR 2 would "explode the deficit, raise costs for the American people and businesses, deny an estimated 32 million people health insurance, and take us back to the days when insurers could deny, limit or drop coverage for any American." President Obama said he would veto HR 2 if it was approved by the House and Senate and presented to him.
- Opponents note that the National Federation of Independent Businesses (NFIB) study was done in January of 2009, and based on an earlier version of the reform legislation. The NFIB assumed that all employers would be required to offer insurance, and that employers would have to pay half the cost of premiums.
In fact, the final version of the bill signed in 2010 exempts companies with 50 or fewer workers from any mandate. When the NFIB estimated that 1.6 million jobs would be lost, they were projecting that nearly one-third of those jobs would be lost at firms with 19 or fewer workers. In addition, the NFIB study assumed that another 420,600 jobs would disappear at firms with 20 to 99 employees. As Politifact.com points out, "presumably a good percentage of those are companies with 50 or fewer employees, and again, are exempt from the health care mandate." - Opponents also pointed out that the Congressional Budget Office reported that the legislation "will reduce the amount of labor used in the economy by a small amount – roughly half a percent – primarily by reducing the amount of labor thatworkers choose to supply."
Today, some workers stay in their jobs because they need health insurance. Under reform, they will have options – many will qualify for subsidies that will help them buy insurance in the Health Exchanges. As a result, CBO explains "a small segment of the population may voluntarily choose to work less." But this does not mean that their jobs were "killed" by health reform legislation.
02/02/2011 | Status: Senate motion rejected |
More: select a member to see his or her other key health care votes.
Yes (47) | ||
---|---|---|
R | Lisa Murkowski | AK |
R | Jefferson Sessions | AL |
R | Richard Shelby | AL |
R | John Boozman | AR |
R | Jon Kyl | AZ |
R | John McCain | AZ |
R | Marco Rubio | FL |
R | Saxby Chambliss | GA |
R | John Isakson | GA |
R | Charles Grassley | IA |
R | Michael Crapo | ID |
R | James Risch | ID |
R | Mark Kirk | IL |
R | Daniel Coats | IN |
R | Richard Lugar | IN |
R | Jerry Moran | KS |
R | Pat Roberts | KS |
R | Mitch McConnell | KY |
R | Rand Paul | KY |
R | David Vitter | LA |
R | Scott Brown | MA |
R | Susan Collins | ME |
R | Olympia Snowe | ME |
R | Roy Blunt | MO |
R | Thad Cochran | MS |
R | Roger Wicker | MS |
R | Richard Burr | NC |
R | John Hoeven | ND |
R | Mike Johanns | NE |
R | Kelly Ayotte | NH |
R | John Ensign | NV |
R | Robert Portman | OH |
R | Thomas Coburn | OK |
R | James Inhofe | OK |
R | Patrick Toomey | PA |
R | Jim DeMint | SC |
R | Lindsey Graham | SC |
R | John Thune | SD |
R | Lamar Alexander | TN |
R | Bob Corker | TN |
R | John Cornyn | TX |
R | Kay Hutchison | TX |
R | Orrin Hatch | UT |
R | Mike Lee | UT |
R | Ron Johnson | WI |
R | John Barrasso | WY |
R | Michael Enzi | WY |
No (51) Our pick | ||
---|---|---|
D | Mark Begich | AK |
D | Mark Pryor | AR |
D | Barbara Boxer | CA |
D | Dianne Feinstein | CA |
D | Michael Bennet | CO |
D | Mark Udall | CO |
D | Richard Blumenthal | CT |
D | Thomas Carper | DE |
D | Chris Coons | DE |
D | Bill Nelson | FL |
D | Daniel Akaka | HI |
D | Daniel Inouye | HI |
D | Thomas Harkin | IA |
D | Richard Durbin | IL |
D | Mary Landrieu | LA |
D | John Kerry | MA |
D | Benjamin Cardin | MD |
D | Barbara Mikulski | MD |
D | Carl Levin | MI |
D | Debbie Stabenow | MI |
D | Alan Franken | MN |
D | Amy Klobuchar | MN |
D | Claire McCaskill | MO |
D | Max Baucus | MT |
D | Jon Tester | MT |
D | Kay Hagan | NC |
D | Kent Conrad | ND |
D | Ben Nelson | NE |
D | Jeanne Shaheen | NH |
D | Frank Lautenberg | NJ |
D | Robert Menendez | NJ |
D | Jeff Bingaman | NM |
D | Tom Udall | NM |
D | Harry Reid | NV |
D | Kirsten Gillibrand | NY |
D | Charles Schumer | NY |
D | Sherrod Brown | OH |
D | Jeff Merkley | OR |
D | Ron Wyden | OR |
D | Robert Casey | PA |
D | John Reed | RI |
D | Sheldon Whitehouse | RI |
D | Tim Johnson | SD |
D | Jim Webb | VA |
D | Patrick Leahy | VT |
I | Bernard Sanders | VT |
D | Maria Cantwell | WA |
D | Patty Murray | WA |
D | Herbert Kohl | WI |
D | Joe Manchin | WV |
D | John Rockefeller | WV |
Not Voting (2) | ||
---|---|---|
I | Joseph Lieberman | CT |
D | Mark Warner | VA |